Sermon, Second Sunday before Advent, 15 November 2026 – the Vicar

  • General Synod is the Church of England’s national assembly. Established in 1970, it has three Houses:
  • The House of Bishops, comprising diocesan bishops and certain other bishops, including elected suffragan representatives.
  • The House of Clergy, largely elected clergy representatives, together with members representing particular constituencies.
  • The House of Laity, largely elected lay representatives.
  • It makes decisions about the Church’s legislation, worship and wider life.
  • Some decisions require separate agreement from each House, making the relationship between bishops, clergy and laity particularly important.
  • What is synodical government for?
    • At its best, synodical government enables the Church to discern together its task for the present.
  • What our governance structure should be aware of
    •  Clericalism arises when ordained status becomes a reason to defer to someone beyond their competence or exempt them from scrutiny. It can diminish lay contributions and make challenge feel like disloyalty.
    • Members need to understand how priorities are set and decisions made. Otherwise, national or diocesan strategies can feel disconnected from local ministry.
    • It’s not a bad principle (though uncomfortable), that the laity should be sceptical and need convincing about anything the clergy propose, and the clergy should be sceptical about anything the Bishops propose. This is not built in disagreement, it is how to stimulate healthy debate.

This leads us to consider what Agreement itself is.

You might think that either we agree or we disagree; either we are united or divided. But there are different kinds of disagreement.

And agreement, too, has its degrees and nuances.

  • There is unanimity, when everyone reaches the same conclusion.
  • There is consensus, when a common mind emerges, even though some retain reservations.
  • There is substantial agreement, when we recognise that a proposal is the best way forward, even if it is not everything we might have wished.
  • And there is the agreement to accept a decision and work together, even while continuing to hold a different view.

The question, then, is not whether the Church will have disagreements. It will. The question is whether it can handle them in a way which is truthful and faithful to the Gospel.

What will the Synod be debating:

You may have gathered that the last 14 years of Archbishop Justin’s leadership begged many questions. An emptying of established processes in a policy called Reform and Renewal sluiced released vast expenditure on projects with no tangible result.

The parish system was undermined with central church resource directed towards so-called church-planting – with nothing to show for it.

  • 900 projects were funded and only 5 of those were amongst high church parishes.
  • £176 million was spent which was forecast in 2017 to result in growth of 90,000 worshippers, in fact 12,700 people were received into the Church, while 200,000 stopped attending all together.
  • 40% of the churches which closed were in the 10% of most deprived churches only increasing the downward cycle of church attendance.

Well-informed commentators have galvanised new representatives to stand for this current Synod, and the driving ideology behind the dismantling of the parish system will to be called to account.

There is a disparity between the wealth of the Church Commissioners and the almost bankrupt state of several dioceses. 35 of the 42 are running deficit budgets. I hope some discussion about how to assist these ailing dioceses can take place with the money going to support struggling parishes

A subject which I am involved in is a crisis in Theological training. Colleges are required to do far more with far less, and made to feel like failures if they run out of money. Supply and demand are not equalled in terms of numbers. Not long ago there were 9000 licensed clergy, there are now just over 6000, and 500 people are leaving licensed ministry each year only being replaced by just over 300 being ordained. It’s a salami slicing operation.

Only 3.9% of clergy in a massive survey regard the Church’s leadership as a “source of hope”.

I could go on with listing depressing statistics. Suffice it to say the General Synod has lots to discuss. Institutional paralysis is not an option. All elected members and all Bishops need our prayers as the King inaugurates its first session.

What has this to do with our readings? Zephaniah foresees the Day of Lord. Not the end of the age, but a day of reckoning. Matthew 25 is a series of parables, the last of which we will have next Sunday for Christ the King. They are all addressing a moment of culmination and judgement. The parable of the Talents is one of those mysterious stories which Jesus specialised in. Its meaning is elusive. Don’t we pity the timorous servant who held on to what he was given for fear of losing it.

There are many interpretations and I oscillate on the best, we are meant to be kept on our toes in reading it.

The Jewish authorities have been castigated already in chapter 21 in the parable of the vineyard and its tenants. I think this remains Matthew’s message. And remember when he is writing, he is writing as a Jew partly to his Jewish confreres, he’s not intending this as antisemitism. But the authorities were entrusted with the great treasure of the Temple and the Law, and rather than multiplying that blessing, they have buried and hidden it.

If this lesson is directed at religious authorities of our day and dispensation, may they be courageous in honouring their tasks and listening to the mind of the Church. And may we all attend to the reality of the Day of the Lord, who gives us this day and all days, our daily bread.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

two × 1 =